• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
WebSetNet

WebSetNet

Technology News

  • Technology News
    • Mobile
    • Games
  • Internet Marketing
  • System Admin
    • Windows
    • Linux
    • Mac & Apple
    • Website Scripts
      • Wordpress

Google stops challenging most US warrants for data on overseas servers

August 5, 2020 by Martin6

Google has quietly stopped challenging most search warrants from US judges in which the data requested is stored on overseas servers, according to the Justice Department.

The revelation, contained in a new court filing to the Supreme Court, comes as the administration of President Donald Trump is pressing the justices to declare that US search warrants served on the US tech sector extend to data stored on foreign servers.

Google and other services began challenging US warrants for overseas data after a federal appeals court sided with Microsoft last year in a first-of-its-kind challenge. Microsoft convinced the New York-based 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals—which has jurisdiction over Connecticut, New York, and Vermont—that US search-and-seizure law does not require compliance with a warrant to turn over e-mail stored on its servers in Ireland. Federal prosecutors were demanding the data as part of a US drug investigation.

In the aftermath, courts outside the 2nd Circuit, which are not bound by the ruling, began rejecting the circuit’s decision and dismissing fresh challenges by the ISPs, including those brought by Google, Yahoo, and Microsoft. In one instance, Google was even found in contempt of court (PDF) for refusing to comply with a District of Columbia federal judge’s order to hand over data stored overseas.

The Supreme Court has not decided whether to hear the government’s challenge to the Microsoft decision, which has huge privacy ramifications for consumers and for the tech sector. The sector is being asked by the US government to comply with court orders that sometimes conflict with the laws of where the data is stored.

Data wars

Google’s move is a break from Microsoft, which, according to the Justice Department filing, “continues to rely” on the 2nd Circuit’s decision on a nationwide basis and is “refusing to produce communications that previously would have been disclosed as a matter of course.”

In seeking the high court to enter this international legal thicket, the Justice Department told the justices that Yahoo and Google have lost before 11 different judges in five different federal circuits and have not prevailed on the issue outside the 2nd Circuit. The Justice Department noted that the controversy is ripe for the justices to review because there are conflicting opinions across the country, in addition to varying compliance behaviors from service providers.

In a document sent to the Supreme Court, the Justice Department wrote (PDF):

Google has reversed its previous stance and informed the government that it will comply with new Section 2703 warrants outside the 2nd Circuit (while suggesting that it will appeal the adverse decisions in one or more existing cases). Consequently, the government’s ability to use Section 2703 warrants to obtain communications stored abroad—which may contain evidence critical to criminal or national-security investigations—now varies depending on the jurisdiction and the identity of the provider.

Supreme Court silence

Microsoft was not immediately prepared to comment. Oath, which owns the Yahoo brand, said in a statement that “We carefully review all requests for user data. We have previously objected, and will continue to object, to process that is over broad or inconsistent with applicable law.”

Google, in a statement, told Ars that it supported recently introduced legislation (PDF) authorizing Internet service providers to surrender overseas data with a warrant.

We’re continuing to follow the Second Circuit Court of Appeals’ decision and will decline to produce data stored overseas in courts that fall within that circuit. To seek consistency in the law, we are appealing some of the cases where lower courts have decided not to follow the ruling of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals. This discrepancy in court decisions is yet another reminder that data surveillance laws need to be modernized to safeguard users’ privacy, protect law enforcement’s legitimate need to collect digital evidence, and provide clarity. We are pleased that both houses of Congress have introduced bills that address these issues.

The US government claims that where the tech sector stores data should not matter. What matters is whether a company can access that data in the US, according to the Justice Department.

The Justice Department initially asked the Supreme Court in June to review the Microsoft decision. The justices have not yet said whether they would hear the case in their upcoming term, which starts October 2.

Source

Related posts:

  1. Mobile Tracking – A Comprehensive Understanding of What, Why, & How
  2. The Amazon Echo Buds (2nd Gen) fix everything wrong with the 1st Gen buds
  3. How to turn on dark mode in Google apps (Update: Now including more apps)
  4. Google Home tips and tricks: Master your Mini, Max, Hub and Hub Max
  5. Google Home tips and tricks: Master your Nest Mini, Max, Audio, Hub and Hub Max
  6. The Beginner’s Guide to Structured Data for Organizing & Optimizing Your Website
  7. The Ultimate Guide to Google Sheets
  8. The Ultimate Guide to Google Docs
  9. Full Fix: Microsoft Edge window position issues
  10. Google Pixel 5 review: The best Pixel ever

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Primary Sidebar

Trending

  • How to fix Windows Update Error 80244019
  • Windows 10 Update keeps failing with error 0x8007001f – 0x20006
  • How To Change Netflix Download Location In Windows 10
  • Troubleshoot Outlook “Not implemented” Unable to Send Email Error
  • How do I enable or disable Alt Gr key on Windows 10 keyboard
  • How To Install Android App APK on Samsung Tizen OS Device
  • 3 Ways To Open PST File Without Office Outlook In Windows 10
  • FIX: Windows Update error 0x800f0986
  • How to Retrieve Deleted Messages on Snapchat
  • Latest Samsung Galaxy Note 20 leak is a spec dump revealing key features
  • Install Android 7.0 Nougat ROM on Galaxy Core 2 SM-G355H
  • 192.168.1.1 Login, Admin Page, Username, Password | Wireless Router Settings
  • Websites to Watch Movies Online – 10+ Best Websites Without SignUp/Downloading
  • How to Backup SMS Messages on Your Android Smartphone
  • How to delete a blank page at the end of a Microsoft Word document
  • Fix: The Disc Image File Is Corrupted Error In Windows 10
  • Android 11 Custom ROM List – Unofficially Update Your Android Phone!
  • Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 3 could be scheduled for June 2021, with S Pen support

Footer

Tags

Amazon amazon prime amazon prime video Apple Application software epic games Galaxy Note 20 Galaxy S22 Plus Galaxy S22 Ultra Google Sheets headphones Huawei icloud Instagram instant gaming ip address iPhone iphone 12 iphone 13 iphone 13 pro max macOS Microsoft Microsoft Edge Mobile app office 365 outlook Pixel 6 Samsung Galaxy Samsung Galaxy Book 2 Pro 360 Samsung Galaxy Tab S8 Smartphone speedtest speed test teams tiktok Twitter vpn WhatsApp whatsapp web Windows 10 Windows 11 Changes Windows 11 Release Windows 11 Update Windows Subsystem For Android Windows 11 Xiaomi

Archives

  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org